Yeah, sorry... I saw too late that the template was just intended as a kind of quality sample and not as a draft for the WP page... I should read more thoroughly before I post something.
Anyway, it's not that different from what I had in mind: A broad horizontal bar at the top, a side bar at the left, and the main frame in the lower right area of the screen. Only the bottom bar is superfluous IMHO. No problem, though - what I wrote into that screenie applies for any design, so no damage has happened.
What exactly do you mean by "he adds the reviews manually"? You are referring to the "official" reviews, right? The ones by the CSM reviewers, I suppose. I think the readers' comments are added automatically... and boy, are those stupid in 80% of all cases! o_O
A separation between "official" waypoint comments & ratings and player ratings looks indeed like a good thing to do...
In our waypoint list, it could look like this:
-------------------------------------------------------
WPU rating: ***
User rating: ****
-------------------------------------------------------